Home
Overview SITEMAP
CONTACT & MAIL
INDOOR AIR
TECHNOLOGIES
BUYER BEWARE
ALLERGY AIR PURIFIER
Reviews TOP 10
PURIFIER REVIEWS
IQ AIR PURIFIER
BLUEAIR
AUSTIN AIR
RABBIT AIR
SHARP AIR PURIFIER
HONEYWELL
HOLMES
ECOQUEST
CAR AIR PURIFIERS
Health Hazards AIRBORNE DISEASE
FORMALDEHYDE
SEARCH SITE
RESOURCES/LINKS
GLOSSARY


Air Purifiers for Formaldehyde Removal


Nobody thinks about buying an air purifier for removing formaldehyde when there isn't a health problem

Symptoms seemed to come from nowhere, now it's an "allergy."

Maybe you just moved into a brand new doublewide mobile home?

Or maybe it's a new site-built house with gas appliances and wall to wall formaldehyde emissions.

Sold the ancestral home and used the proceeds to buy a retirement RV and go south for the winter?

Cool.

Until the FEMA RV trailer formaldehyde scandal hit the wire.

You just applied multiple coats of oil-based paint, which takes up to 18 months to out-gas, to your heirloom furniture from great grandma.

Yikes.

The cabinet guy said the smell would only last a week....

Or could it be the new $10,000 leather furniture?


Hotel California: Toxic Traps


I know many folks are trapped in their current living arrangement by the "sub-prime lending crisis."

But everyone should have a long term plan for purging their lives of these toxins.

Removing all formaldehyde sources from the home should be the first step in reducing exposure. But often that is simply not feasible in the short term.

The purchase of an air purifier should be considered a temporary solution to continuous formaldehyde emissions in the home.

When it comes to gas phase Volatile Organic Chemicals (VOCs) like formaldehyde, the great majority of air purifiers, despite advertising claiming the ability to eliminate VOC pollutants, simply cannot do the job.

VOCs go right through paper HEPA filter media, which is designed to capture only particles. Carbon impregnated polyester wrap around prefilters will capture formaldehyde for maybe the first three weeks. Some of these you can see right through.

Air purifiers must be specifically designed to remove formaldehyde, most are not.

There is little real evidence on the effectiveness of residential purifiers at removing airborne formaldehyde.

Continuous source emissions which come from building materials or furnishings are the most difficult for air purification equipment to eliminate.

In industrial settings, expensive real-time monitoring and air scrubbing is required for formaldehyde abatement.

Residential air cleaner VOC removing performance over long periods of time is problematic, since subjective odor detection or symptom relief may be the main metrics for evaluation.

In my opinion, formaldehyde is dangerous at levels which may not provoke "allergy" symptoms. Individuals chronically exposed to aldehydes may loose the ability to smell them.

If our only method of timing the replacement of costly gas-phase filters is the return of odors or symptoms, we haven't really eliminated enough of the formaldehyde.

So purifiers that actually remove airborne formaldehyde are going to be expensive, and must run continuously on high fan speeds. To be effective, filter media should be replaced much more frequently than manufacturer recommended intervals.


Which Technology?


Removing aldehydes means we have only a few choices of air cleaning technology. Basically we can capture the gas or destroy it by oxidation.

An air purifier with at least 6 lbs. of activated carbon combined with activated alumina/potassium permanganate and/or potassium iodide would be my main choice. Plain activated carbon won't be nearly as effective.

In outdoor air formaldehydes have a short half-life, just a few hours. Ultraviolet frequencies in sunlight create reactive hydroxyl radicals, and formaldehyde is readily photo-oxidized to carbon dioxide.

But indoors there is relative darkness.

This suggests that oxidizing air cleaners might be the answer to formaldehyde.

Many ozone generators are advertised as being suitable for formaldehyde abatement.

They are not, because the source is a continuous background emission, and ozone concentrations high enough to suppress these are toxic.

Aldehydes are often absorbed onto surfaces and textiles, like carpets, furniture, and curtains. These will take months to outgas.

Ozone is well suited to one time shock treatments, it is perfect for eliminating entrenched mold.

But if you are living in a new mobile home, or worse, a US government FEMA trailer, and absolutely cannot escape, a high powered ozone generator rental might help.

Let it run for 72 hours while your family stays elsewhere.


Photocatalytic Oxidation (PCO)


Photocatalytic air purifiers can actually remove VOCs.

Photocatalysts destroy indoor air pollutants using ultraviolet light energy bombarding a light-sensitive surface. When energized, oxidation and reduction reactions occur on the catalyst surface, converting organic pollutants to carbon dioxide and water.

For the uninitiated, here is my page devoted to PCO: Photocatalytic Purification

Experimental results have cast some doubt as to the completeness of the oxidation in the many hastily designed less costly PCO tack-ons now flooding the market.

Without a powerful lamp, intense UV exposure, and significant dwell time in the chamber, partially oxidized byproducts escape.

This calls the "just carbon dioxide and water remain" claims into question.

Air purifiers with PCO should be designed around the main technology. Most PCO purifiers are not properly engineered to significantly expunge continuous source formaldehyde.

Hydroxyl radical ionizers also claim to eliminate formaldehyde. When combined with sensors which sniff the most common VOC, these would be a lower priced alternative.

My Sharp Plasmacluster ionizer can smell when I need a bath, but I have no idea whether it can respond to low levels of formaldehyde.

I am surprised that no manufacturer of air purifiers has stepped forward to volunteer their aldehyde-capable air purification equipment to New Orleans hurricane victims trapped in toxic FEMA trailers.

What a missed marketing opportunity.


Recommended Purifiers for Formaldehyde


I warned you this wouldn't be cheap.

IQAir GCX Chemisorber ($2,199.00) is very good at removing formaldehyde and other VOCs.

IQAir GC Chemisorber ($1,199.00) air purifiers are well suited to removal of Formaldehyde.

A standard IQAir pre-filter is followed by four filter cartridges loaded with complex gas phase media.

These filter cartridges hold 12 pounds of the carbon-potassium permanganate media.

CG's have a total of nine replacement filters and are obviously expensive to maintain.

AllerAir D-series, especially the DX and DXVOC, around $1,000, are good VOC removers, but have no HEPA filter for particles.

Airpura P600 $1,000 photocatalytic and carbon, expensive upkeep.

Allerair 6000 Vocarb $1000, air purifiers with 18 pounds of blended activated carbon and HEPA, are a mid-priced option for removing continuous emitting aldehydes.

AustinAir Healthmate Plus $648.99 with 15 lbs. "Superblend" carbon/zeolite filter impregnated with potassium iodide

Air Oasis 3000 $374.99, low ozone photocat, no filters to buy, very long 3-year cell replacement interval.

Aireox 45D $309.00, with "purafil' potassium permanganate and carbon, for a small room.




Sylvane carries IQAir Chemisorber Air Purifiers

In a world of mass merchandising and impersonal internet dealers, www.Sylvane.com stands out.

The president of Sylvane is a fellow allergy sufferer and, while this a compensated endorsement, Sylvane makes no attempt to comprise air-purifier-power's objectivity.

Sylvane's in-house (not outsourced) customer service is happy to work with customers to find the right product to solve their problem.

Sylvane carries a wide range of home-cleaning appliances, and looks beyond each sale, since repeat customers are the core of their business.

In researching Sylvane, here is what I found;

standard manufacturer's pricing adhered to,

no shipping charges for the lower 48 states, except on returns.

ships high percentage of orders with amazing speed.

30 day liberal return policy, no restocking fees, user pays return shipping.

promptly responds to e-mail.

has e-Bay store with 1353 feedback responses
99.3% positive. Experienced e-Bayers know this is rare.

has Amazon store with 406 ratings over the past 12 months yield 4.8 stars, Sylvane responds to all negative remarks.

at epinions.com there are 14 sylvane.com buyer reviews, averaging 4.5 stars, in the Online-Stores-and-Services section.

secured hacker-proof connection accepts virtually all forms of payment.

No internet store is perfect, but Sylvane.com is among the best.

I routinely order filters from Sylvane.com, they arrive in 4 to 7 days with no discrepancies.

Sylvane carries IQAir Chemisorber Air Purifiers


End Formaldehyde Removing Air Purifiers, goto Sitemap

Top of Page




"We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them."
Albert Einstein


Recent Posts

Electrolux Oxygen EL500AZ Review

Germ Guardian GG-1000 Review

Holmes Air Purifier Reviews

RabbitAir BioGS SPA-582A Review

Honeywell 50150 Review

Honeywell HFD-110 Review

Honeywell 16200 Review

Sensor-Driven Purifiers Reconsidered

Surround Air XJ-3800 Intelli-Pro Review

Blueair 203 Review

Blueair 603 Review

Winix Plasmawave 5500 Review

Honeywell Air Purifiers

Sharp Plasmascluster FP-A80U Review

Sharp Plasmacluster FP-A60U Review

Sharp Plasmacluster FP-P30U Review

Honeywell HHT-011 "Permanent" "HEPA" Review

Honeywell 50255-HD Home Depot Review

Honeywell HFD-120-q Review

Honeywell HFD-010 Review

Hoover WH10600 "TIO2" Review

Sharp Plasmacluster KC-860U Review

Sharp Plasmacluster KC-850U Review

Sharp Plasmacluster KC-830U Review

"There's so much pollution in the air now that if it weren't for our lungs there'd be no place to put it all."
Robert Orben